Email Marketing Lead Generation Mistakes

Many people believe that email marketing is outdated and ineffective for lead generation. However, this couldn’t be further from the truth. Not only is the number of daily email users continually growing but also email marketing delivers a much higher ROI compared to social media (SM) campaigns.

To give you some numbers, an average ROI from SM campaigns is $2.80 for every dollar spent – this is almost 15 times less than what you could make from one email marketing campaign!

“Email has an ability many channels don’t: creating valuable, personal touches — at scale. – David Newman”

Sounds unbelievable? If so, then it’s likely that you’re making mistakes that prevent you from making the most out of your lead generation effects. The good news? You’ve come to this source. Here, we’ll tell you what email marketing lead generation mistakes marketers typically make in their campaigns and how to refine your strategy to ensure the leads start flowing in.

Understanding Lead Generation in Email Marketing

In email marketing, lead generation is about much more than just sending emails. It’s about sending the right emails to the right people and at the right time.

Put simply, it’s the process of collecting leads through opt-in forms. When your target audience shares their personal information such as names and emails, you get leads that you can store in your database and use for marketing activities.

And while social media is great for its engagement, emails still remain one of the most direct and personalized ways to communicate with people. However, if your marketing efforts don’t bring the desired results, then you must be doing something wrong.

Let’s take a look at the common mistakes many marketers make and discuss how they could be avoided.

Common Email Marketing Lead Generation Mistakes to Avoid

Email marketing success hinges on delivering the right message to the right people, making audience segmentation absolutely crucial. Blasting identical emails to your entire contact list is like throwing spaghetti at the wall – you might get lucky occasionally, but you’re wasting both time and potential.

Each subscriber has unique needs, interests, and pain points that deserve tailored attention. Without proper segmentation, you risk sending irrelevant content that not only fails to convert but could also damage your sender reputation and lead to higher unsubscribe rates.

The most successful email marketers understand that segmentation isn’t just about basic demographics – it’s about creating targeted groups based on behavior patterns, engagement levels, and purchase history to ensure every message resonates with its intended recipients. Think of segmentation as the foundation of your email marketing strategy; without it, even the most brilliantly crafted campaigns may fall flat.

Not Segmenting Your Audience

Source: Unsplash

This is one of the most common mistakes. When marketers don’t spend enough time researching their audience, they fail to understand who they’re targeting and just send the same email to the entire contact list. Now, how many people would reply to an email that looks and feels completely irrelevant to them? Not a lot.

People have different needs and preferences. They may also come from different age groups, and sending them all the same template is a missed opportunity. Sure, you might have a few successful hits, but instead of having 70-80% open rates, you’ll likely see your email being sent to trash in the majority of cases.

Therefore, one of the first steps you should take before you even start working on your email design should be to define your audience and segment them into several groups based on their age, preferences, and behaviors. This will help enhance engagement and increase click-through rates.

Here are a few tips to help you out:

• Create detailed user personas;
• Conduct surveys to better understand your audience’s needs;
• Segment your audience into smaller groups to measure the impact of emails.

Weak Content Marketing

Source: Unsplash

Another common issue with emails is the lack of a powerful message. They just look like yet another spammy email that has accidentally landed in the inbox. Content marketing and email marketing are tightly related, making it crucial to craft engaging, high-quality content for your email campaigns.

Take the time to come up with a powerful subject line. This is the first thing people see when they check their emails, and if your heading isn’t compelling, most likely, they won’t bother opening it.

The content itself should be catchy, engaging, and valuable. One of the best ways to engage an audience is to offer them something for free. Is there a newsletter or eBook you can offer for a subscription? Or maybe you’ve got a series of videos they may be interested in to download?

Consider what your competition is doing to attract leads and see how you can implement it in your emails. At the end of the day, there’s nothing wrong with taking a sneak peek at what works for others and adding your unique twist to it.

Ignoring Mobile Optimization

Source: Pexels

Over 1.7 billion people are opening emails from their mobile devices, which equals almost half of all emails. This means if your email isn’t optimized for mobile, you’re missing out on a huge chunk of potential leads.

With that in mind, make sure to test your email before sending out your email campaign. Check how it looks on various devices and email clients. Most email marketing platforms have preview tools for this, but it’s always a good idea to manually check how your email pops up on different screens.

In addition to choosing a responsive template, you want your email to have a clean and enticing design. Visual content is a powerful way to engage your audience, but it should be optimized to produce the desired effect. First, any images you use should load quickly. And second, they shouldn’t obscure the rest of the content, causing users to scroll them.

Inconsistent Sending Schedule

Sending emails at the wrong time can be a reason for low engagement rates. The same is true for sending emails too frequently. If you shoot your campaigns every other day, people may get bored of them pretty quickly and decide to unsubscribe. Striking the right balance is key.

A good practice is to send no more than two emails a week. Anything more than that might overwhelm your audience. Also, you should stick to a specific time in your calendar. The best time to send emails is usually in the morning when people only come to work, but you can also try midday – a lot of people go through their emails after lunchtime.

Not A/B Testing

Source: Unsplash

Assuming you know what works without testing is a big mistake. Even the best tips don’t guarantee you successful campaigns. It’s only when you test emails that you can build your own formula of success and refine your strategy to grow your list of leads.

Here’s a recipe for a great email, according to Dan Munz, a public digital leader at Ad Hoc LLC: “1. Write your email. 2. Delete most of it. 3. Send”.  You will end up with your own recipe that will be the most effective for you.

That’s where A/B testing plays a crucial role. Once you segment your audience, split them again to test different elements of an email. This will allow you to evaluate which subject lines, layouts, and CTAs are having the most impact and create highly engaging emails that resonate with your audience.

No Proper Follow-Up Process

A follow-up process is an important part of the lead generation process, and if it’s not organized properly, this can be the cause of lost leads. Not only should you be sending follow-up emails if your first batch didn’t result in conversions but you should also be quick to reply if any inquiries come in.

Ideally, you want multiple tailored templates to address the needs of different people. But if you want to take your email lead generation campaigns a step further, take advantage of automation tools. Many CRMs offer automation features that can do follow-ups for you, as well as send reminders to ensure that no lead gets overlooked.

Not Doing Data Analysis

Source: Unsplash

Marketing is all about data. You can’t sell or generate leads without understanding the impact of your actions. Measuring key performance indicators after sending each new campaign gives you a clear idea of what works for your target audience and what doesn’t and should be improved.

In email marketing, there are three major figures to keep track of. These are:

• Conversion rate;
• Click through rate;
• Cost per lead (CPL).

Here’s what they mean and how you can improve them for optimal performance:

You can review this data either in CRM or use the GA dashboard offering in-depth analysis of user behavior.

These numbers tell you how effective your campaign is. For example, if your CR is high but your CPL is also high, you’re getting results but not as efficiently as you could be. On the other hand, if your CTR is low but lots of people are opening your emails, it means they are interested but not motivated enough to take action – maybe the CTA needs slight tweaking.

Conclusion

To sum it up, email marketing is by no chance outdated or a thing of the past. It’s a powerful tool in the hands of marketers to generate leads if handled properly. People still use emails, and we can’t see this change any time soon.

However, people are becoming more demanding. It’s not enough just to throw at them an average template and expect them to turn into leads. To cut through the noise of all those emails that spam inboxes every day, you need to invest time into creating a campaign that stands out and just can’t be missed.

Hopefully, now that you know what common mistakes to avoid, you’re all set to make your email marketing efforts more effective. Take these tips, put them into action, and watch your campaigns bring leads.